Forgot your password?
Or sign in with one of these services
We would be honored if you would join us...
Andy, July 20, 2007 in Star Wars Saga
16 members have voted
They all have their pros and cons.. but in this case I think the cons of AOTC outweight the pros.
Bah, who voted for TPM? Cowards haven't even posted... :p
You can't see who voted for what with your admin powers?
I voted for TPM. The boneheadedness of Jar Jar Binks and Jake Lloyd overpowered the amazing lightsaber fights and other coolish things.
I'm in the majority!
You and the nameless ones to embarrassed to admit their choice.
Why would anyone be embarassed to dislike TPM? It's pretty much the most obvious choice.
Well, they haven't revealed themselves, just the same.
Though, I think all the cheesey romance plus whiny little Anakin boy trumps Jar Jar.
Plus there were better battle and fights in TPM than in AOTC.
Anakin angst was required to show his inner turmoil on his path to becoming a Sith. Having a creature as annoying as Jar Jar was pointless.
The fights in AotC were slightly less cool than the Maul/Obi/Qui duel. Slightly.
TPM was just all around more enjoyable, I think... no matter what was in it or not...
I just had a better time watching it. I think it had more exciting scenes.
AOTC just had some boring parts.. and it seemed almost like a forced filler between Ep I and III.
Just think, if I hadn't liked TPM, you wouldn't be here posting on this site. :p
you're entitled to your opinion. even if it's wrong. :p
Ah, now it is two-on-two. My companions are slowly revealing themselves. Bwahahaha!
3 on 2 actually
AOTC was abit boring
al dat romantic stuff and i hate anakin in it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I like this new member already!
TPM is a kiddie story, whereas the plot of AOTC has political intrigue, war, mystery, angst, etc. It's much more grown up.
And the Battle of Geonosis is one of the best sequences in both trilogies.
I voted for TPM
I understand that Lucas needed to make someone so INCREDIBLY stupid that they would vote emergency powers to Palpatine, but damn....he could have made them have a mentality greater than an 8 year old!
And I'm sorry, he DID screw up all the good battle scenes. One second you're watching Obi Wan and Maul, the next second he's jugging water---kinda ruined it for me.
Effing right. ;)
But the battle on Geonosis was so short and boring, just like the battle of Hoth.
The battle of Naboo/Duel of the Fates was almost just as exciting, for me, as the battle of Endor/Luke vs Vader.
Urgh, sacrilege... TPM is so under-rated. :p
Well it looks like it's being rated as twice as worse as AotC, to me. :lol:
No worries D! You've got the stouborn opinionated Rogue in your corner ;)
We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.